A federal judge in Eugene, Oregon, has found that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers broke the law when they took a 56-year-old Albany man into custody outside a Walmart in June, after agency witnesses conceded they had been running shoppers’ license plates without targeting anyone in particular.
U.S. District Judge Mustafa T. Kasubhai announced the decision from the bench on Friday, Nov. 20, 2026, at the close of an evidentiary hearing on the man’s habeas petition. He said a written opinion will follow.
Testimony Revealed Random Plate Checks
Several ICE officers took the stand, including a Portland-based supervisor identified in court only by his initials. He acknowledged that on June 18 his team was not hunting for a specific person with a deportation order. Instead, officers checked plates on vehicles in store parking lots in Albany and Dallas, Oregon, hoping to find people living in the country without authorization.
A text message the supervisor sent his team that morning, read aloud in court, suggested starting at local “landmarks” and listed the addresses of two Walmart stores. Asked why those stores were chosen, he said Walmart opens early and his shifts begin early, and that grocery lots are where people are on the move. He denied picking the towns because of their Latino and working-class immigrant communities.
Kasubhai remarked that he had heard of no comparable sweeps at upscale shopping destinations in the Portland area.
Warrant Never Served, No Flight-Risk Review
The petitioner, a Mayan speaker who testified through an interpreter, has lived in Oregon for 35 years, runs a pallet-repair company with three employees and holds a work permit. His removal case is set for a hearing in February. He was walking back to his truck with water and bread for his crew when officers detained him.
The judge concluded that any warrant was invalid because officers never served it, read it to him or told him it existed, and the government could show no record of service. He also ruled that treating the stop as a warrantless arrest failed because officers never assessed whether the man was likely to flee. Kasubhai called the petitioner the most credible witness of the day and declared that “the arrest itself is unlawful.”
Broader Orders From the Bench
After his release, the man was driven from Portland to the Tacoma area and back, then left roughly 70 miles from home. Kasubhai directed ICE to stop stranding released detainees and to return them to their hometowns or to the vehicles they left behind.
The judge also said he will hold evidentiary hearings and require federal officers to testify in every immigration detention habeas case assigned to him, until a higher authority tells him otherwise. Whether the Oregon operations were racially motivated will be addressed in a separate class action, in which Kasubhai has already barred ICE officers in the state from making warrantless arrests.
