A federal judge in Connecticut has ruled that the artificial intelligence prompts an expert witness’s team used to sift through Shell’s internal documents are fair game in discovery, a decision that could shape how expert witnesses use generative AI in litigation.
U.S. District Judge Vernon D. Oliver on Friday overruled objections from the Conservation Law Foundation and affirmed a magistrate judge’s order requiring the environmental group to produce the prompts and queries behind the work of its expert, Harvard science historian Naomi Oreskes. The group has until Dec. 18, 2026, to comply.
How AI Entered the Expert Report
The foundation sued Shell Oil Products US and related companies in 2021, alleging that the company’s fuel terminal in New Haven, Connecticut, is not prepared for flooding and storms and could expose surrounding neighborhoods and waterways to hazardous substances. Shell denies the claims.
Oreskes was retained to testify for the foundation. According to the court’s order, a research assistant on her team, computational scientist Alexander Kaurov, processed Shell’s document production in a dedicated Microsoft Azure environment and used ChatGPT to search the materials and flag documents for Oreskes to review. Prompts, queries and model outputs were used interactively along the way, but complete logs of those exchanges were not preserved.
Shell moved to compel the prompts. In May 2026, Magistrate Judge Thomas O. Farrish granted that request, concluding that an expert’s methodology is a proper subject of discovery and that the AI-driven process for narrowing the document set was part of that methodology. The order was put on hold while the foundation objected.
Prompts Versus Protected Notes
The foundation argued that the prompts were outside the scope of discovery, that they amounted to expert notes the parties had agreed not to exchange, and that disclosing the search terms already produced was enough.
Judge Oliver disagreed. He found that the prompts form part of “the basis” for Oreskes’s opinions, which federal rules require experts to disclose, and that they are distinct from notes tied to draft reports that may otherwise be shielded. He also concluded that the parties’ discovery stipulation did not clearly exclude the AI material.
A Growing Fight Over AI in Expert Work
The ruling adds to a small but expanding set of decisions on whether experts must reveal how they used AI tools. At least one other federal court, in a Nevada case involving the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department, reportedly treated an expert’s prompts as protected earlier this fall, pointing to a developing split.
The practical stakes are significant. Expert testimony is a frequent battleground, and access to the instructions an expert gave an AI system could give opposing counsel new ways to probe what documents were reviewed, what was left out and whether the analysis can be reproduced.
The case is Conservation Law Foundation Inc. v. Shell Oil Products US et al., No. 3:21-cv-00933, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut.
