Skip to content

Judge Lets Trump’s $15 Billion Defamation Suit Against the New York Times Move Forward

President Donald Trump’s $15 billion defamation case against the New York Times and book publisher Penguin Random House will continue, after a federal judge in Florida on Thursday, November 19, declined to throw the lawsuit out in its entirety.

U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday, who sits in Tampa, rejected the defendants’ bid for a full dismissal. He did trim the case, however, tossing two claims and narrowing four others, according to reporting on the decision.

What the Lawsuit Targets

The suit centers on reporting by three Times journalists: Susanne Craig, Russ Buettner and Peter Baker. It challenges two articles published by the newspaper and the 2024 book Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success, which Craig and Buettner co-wrote and Penguin Random House published.

Trump contends the material contains false statements about his inheritance, his business record, his upbringing and his role in the reality show The Apprentice, and that those statements harmed both his companies and his personal reputation.

Why Part of the Case Survived

The judge concluded that the complaint plausibly alleges that passages suggesting Trump planned and carried out “complex crimes” rested on “incomplete, minimal information.” Because Trump is a public figure, he must ultimately prove actual malice, meaning the defendants knew a statement was false or recklessly disregarded whether it was true. Merryday signaled that the allegations about how the tax-related assertions were sourced were enough to keep that question alive at this early stage.

Not every claim fared as well. The court dismissed the portion of the case aimed at a Times article about Trump’s work on The Apprentice.

A Rocky Procedural Path

The ruling follows an unusual start to the litigation. Merryday struck Trump’s original 80-page complaint, faulting it for lacking a short, plain statement of the claims and for being filled with what the court called “vituperation and invective.” A slimmer 40-page amended complaint followed in October 2025. Mediation later failed, and the defendants were unsuccessful in an effort to move the case to federal court in New York.

How the Defendants Responded

The Times and Penguin Random House deny defaming Trump and have argued that the suit is legally deficient and politically motivated. A Times spokesperson called the case a baseless attack on the newspaper and on the independent press, while the publisher has said it stands by the book and its authors.

Part of a Broader Media Fight

The decision comes roughly a week after a different federal judge allowed Trump’s defamation suit against the BBC, over an edited speech clip, to go forward. Trump has filed a string of suits against news organizations since 2024, and press-freedom advocates have criticized them as efforts to intimidate journalists. With the core claims intact, the New York Times case now heads toward further litigation over what the reporters knew and how they reached their conclusions.

Sources