A divided federal appeals court has handed prediction market operator Kalshi another loss, ruling that Maryland gaming regulators may pursue the company for offering sports-related event contracts without a state wagering license.
The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, sitting in Richmond, Virginia, voted 2-1 this week to affirm a Baltimore federal judge’s refusal to grant Kalshi a preliminary injunction. The outcome leaves Maryland free to move forward with enforcement and widens a disagreement among federal appellate courts that many observers expect the U.S. Supreme Court to resolve.
How the Dispute Began
The case traces back to a cease-and-desist letter the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission sent Kalshi last year, demanding that it stop offering what the state views as unlicensed sports betting. Kalshi responded with a lawsuit, arguing that its event contracts are regulated exclusively by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission under the Commodity Exchange Act, which would leave no room for state gaming rules.
U.S. District Judge Adam B. Abelson declined to block Maryland’s enforcement efforts, and Kalshi appealed. The panel heard argument in May before issuing its published decision.
Two Judges, Two Paths to the Same Result
The majority affirmed in a short unsigned order, but Circuit Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker each wrote a separate concurrence explaining their reasoning.
Judge Gregory said he did not need to decide whether Kalshi’s sports contracts qualify as “swaps” under federal law. Even assuming they do, he concluded, neither the statute nor the CFTC’s rules clearly show that such contracts can trade on a federally designated exchange beyond the reach of state gaming laws. Because gambling regulation has long been a core state police power, he declined to assume that Congress quietly displaced it. “Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so,” he wrote.
Judge Thacker reached the same bottom line through her own reading of the Commodity Exchange Act.
The Dissent
Judge DeAndrea Benjamin disagreed. In her view, Kalshi’s sports event contracts are swaps, a category of derivatives that falls exclusively under CFTC oversight, which would bar Maryland from regulating them.
Reactions and What Comes Next
Kalshi said the fractured reasoning shows there is no unified, coherent legal theory against prediction markets. Jeremy Baker, acting director of the Maryland commission, welcomed the decision, saying it confirmed the state’s authority to regulate what he called clearly sports wagering.
The ruling arrives as states across the country challenge Kalshi and rival platforms, arguing they operate without licenses and allow betting by people under 21. Two other federal appeals courts have also ruled against Kalshi, while a third found that New Jersey could not regulate it. The CFTC under the current administration has backed the industry’s position that federal oversight is exclusive.
Kalshi, recently valued at $40 billion, now faces a growing patchwork of conflicting appellate decisions, a split that raises the chances the Supreme Court will step in to settle who has the final word over sports event contracts.
