Skip to content

Federal Judge Keeps CFPB’s 2023 Order Against Debt Buyer Portfolio Recovery Associates in Place

A federal judge in Virginia has turned down a request from Portfolio Recovery Associates, one of the largest debt buyers in the country, to be released from a court-enforced settlement it reached with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in 2023. The ruling, issued this week in the Eastern District of Virginia’s Norfolk Division, means the company must keep following the order’s debt collection and credit reporting requirements.

The company had argued that the deal had become too expensive to live with and that the bureau’s enforcement priorities under the Trump administration no longer matched the ones that produced the settlement. The court did not accept either point as a reason to unwind the judgment.

A Settlement Built on an Earlier Order

The 2023 stipulated judgment was the second time federal regulators had addressed the company’s collection practices. The CFPB first issued an order against Portfolio Recovery Associates in 2015. In March 2023, the bureau said the company had violated that order by collecting on debts it could not substantiate, failing to provide required documents and disclosures, and filing lawsuits over debts that were too old to legally enforce.

To resolve those claims, the company agreed to pay more than $12 million in consumer redress and a $12 million civil penalty. The judgment also restricted how it may pursue time-barred debt and required it to properly investigate disputes consumers raise about information it reports to credit bureaus.

Why the Company Wanted Out

Earlier this year, Portfolio Recovery Associates asked the court to terminate the judgment or, in the alternative, modify it under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b). It pointed to a sharp rise in disputes submitted by phone, which it linked to social media “finfluencers” and credit repair organizations, and said handling those disputes was consuming far more resources than anticipated. It also cited the bureau’s changed approach to enforcement.

The CFPB opposed the motion. In its filing, the bureau said the company had not shown a substantial and unforeseen change in circumstances, as Rule 60(b)(5) requires, and had come nowhere near the “extraordinary circumstances” needed for relief under Rule 60(b)(6). The agency characterized the request as a complaint that the deal had simply become inconvenient.

The Court’s Decision

The judge sided with the bureau, concluding that higher compliance costs and a shift in federal enforcement policy did not justify ending or rewriting the settlement. The decision underscores that consent judgments entered by a court do not automatically loosen when the agency that negotiated them changes direction.

What It Means for Consumers

For people contacted by Portfolio Recovery Associates, the protections in the 2023 order remain in force, including the limits on suing over old debts and the duties tied to credit reporting disputes. The ruling may also be watched by other companies operating under Biden-era CFPB orders that hoped the agency’s new posture would give them a path out.

Sources