A national emergency medical services company has agreed to pay $2.2 million to resolve a federal lawsuit over its policy requiring clean-shaven faces. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) says the rule shut out EMTs and paramedics who could not shave because of their faith or a skin condition. For workers, the case is a reminder that an employer’s blanket rule does not always override the law on accommodations.
What Happened
Global Medical Response, Inc., American Medical Response, Inc. and affiliated companies (together, AMR) settled a suit the EEOC brought under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The agency announced the deal this week. The case was filed in federal court in Colorado.
The EEOC alleged that, starting at least in late 2018, AMR enforced a “no beard” rule and turned down requests for exceptions. According to the agency, some workers kept facial hair because of sincerely held religious beliefs, while others had conditions such as pseudofolliculitis barbae, a skin problem often caused by shaving. The EEOC said these workers could have done their jobs safely with an alternative respirator, yet some shaved against their beliefs or medical advice to stay employed, and others were not hired or were let go.
Under the settlement, AMR will fund $2.2 million for a nationwide group of affected applicants and employees. It will also create new EMT and paramedic positions that come with the alternative respirator and take part in an independent study on whether that option could safely be offered in all such roles. The company has denied wrongdoing, and the decree states it is not a finding on the merits. The company also says its respirator standards protect both clinicians and patients.
Background and Legal Context
Title VII requires employers to make reasonable accommodations for an employee’s sincere religious practice unless doing so would cause undue hardship. The ADA similarly requires reasonable accommodations for a disability, again absent undue hardship. Retaliation against someone for asserting these rights is also prohibited. Safety rules can matter in this analysis, but the law generally asks whether a workable alternative exists before a worker is turned away or fired.
The decree covers people who worked or applied for these jobs from January 1, 2018 until the court approves it. Court filings describe the agreement as lasting three years once approved.
What Comes Next
The decree takes effect once the judge approves it, and the money is then paid into a fund for eligible workers. Anyone who believes they were affected will want to watch for official notices about how claims are handled. Separately, employers across many industries may review their own grooming and safety policies for exception procedures.
Sources
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: American Medical Response to Pay $2.2 Million in Nationwide Settlement of EEOC Religion and Disability Discrimination Suit
- FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth: North Texas EMS provider to pay $2.2M to settle federal lawsuit over strict ‘no beard’ policy
- Proposed consent decree, EEOC v. Global Medical Response, Inc., et al., No. 1:22-cv-02544 (D. Colo.)
