A federal judge in New Mexico has refused to dismiss the Justice Department’s lawsuit against the New Mexico Supreme Court and the state’s Board of Bar Examiners. The ruling means the state’s top court and its bar admissions agency must defend claims that they ignored a federal law that lets military families carry professional licenses across state lines.
U.S. District Judge Kea W. Riggs denied both defendants’ motions to dismiss on Nov. 19. The case is the government’s first lawsuit to enforce the license portability provisions of the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA).
A Military Spouse Turned Away
The dispute centers on Liam Lees, an attorney married to an Air Force major who was ordered to Holloman Air Force Base in 2024. Lees trained in law abroad, earned an LL.M. from William & Mary Law School and is licensed in several U.S. states. After the couple moved to Las Cruces, a local district attorney’s office offered him a trial attorney job on the condition that he get a New Mexico license.
According to the complaint, the bar board turned him down because he holds an LL.M. rather than a J.D., and the state supreme court denied his waiver request on a 3-2 vote. Lees later applied again under the SCRA. The board pointed him to a narrower state rule for military spouses, asked for transcripts, test scores and references, charged non-refundable fees, and then treated his application as incomplete. He ended up taking a lower-paying law clerk job instead.
The department sued in June 2026. It alleges that New Mexico has a pattern or practice of refusing to recognize valid out-of-state law licenses held by qualifying servicemembers and their spouses.
What the Court Decided
Judge Riggs made three key findings at the pleading stage. First, she concluded that both the supreme court and the bar board count as “licensing authorities” covered by the SCRA. She rejected the board’s argument that it is exempt because only the court formally grants licenses. If a body can effectively reject applicants by declaring their files incomplete, she reasoned, it is exercising licensing power. Allowing states to hand that job to a subordinate agency would defeat the law’s purpose.
Second, the judge read the statute to allow a criminal background check but not the full character and fitness review that New Mexico requires of first-time bar applicants. Third, she found that the government had alleged enough facts to support its pattern-or-practice theory.
Why It Matters
Congress expanded the SCRA’s portability rules so that frequent military moves would not cost spouses their careers. Many state bars have long treated law licenses differently from other professional credentials. This early ruling suggests that federal courts may hold state high courts to the same portability rules that apply to nurses, teachers and other licensed workers.
The case will now move forward on the merits in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico.
