A federal appeals court has left the Environmental Protection Agency’s 2024 rule banning several remaining uses of chrysotile asbestos in place, dismissing challenges from chemical makers, a major labor union and public health advocates without ever reaching the merits.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled on Nov. 19, 2026, that none of the groups that sought review had shown the legal injury needed to bring their case to federal court. “Because no Petitioner has standing, we DISMISS the petitions for lack of jurisdiction,” Judge Kurt D. Engelhardt wrote for the panel, which also included Judges Edith Brown Clement and Leslie H. Southwick.
A Rule Attacked From Both Sides
The rule, issued under the Toxic Substances Control Act, phases out ongoing uses of chrysotile asbestos, a carcinogen the agency linked to mesothelioma, lung, larynx and ovarian cancers, and asbestosis. Petitions filed in several circuits were consolidated in the Fifth Circuit as Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA.
Four state and national chemistry trade groups argued the ban went too far and asked the court to vacate the provisions affecting the chlor-alkali and chemical production industries. The United Steelworkers union argued the EPA had failed to give chemical plant workers interim protections it offered to others. Health organizations, two firefighter unions and a group of physicians and researchers contended the agency should have banned more types and uses of asbestos.
Standing Raised by the Court Itself
The EPA had not initially contested standing. The panel raised the question on its own shortly before oral argument and later ordered supplemental briefing.
The industry groups, the court said, offered almost no standing argument in their opening brief and could not lean on Olin Corp., a directly regulated company that had joined their brief before dropping its petition. Evidence they filed after argument about member companies came too late, and the panel refused to consider it. The union’s standing claim appeared only in a footnote and never named an affected member, which the court treated as a forfeiture.
The advocacy petitioners did submit declarations on time, but the panel found they described only a generalized, increased risk of asbestos exposure rather than concrete, imminent harm to identifiable members. The court also concluded that the Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization, which has supporters rather than traditional members, had not shown it could sue on their behalf.
What Happens Next
Because the dismissal rests on jurisdiction, the Biden-era ban stays in effect without any ruling on whether the EPA got the science or the procedure right. Trade press noted the outcome contrasts with a separate Fifth Circuit panel’s recent decision vacating the agency’s methylene chloride rule on the merits, a decision the asbestos panel expressly declined to discuss.
The opinion also sends a pointed message to future petitioners challenging agency rules: standing evidence, including affidavits identifying harmed members, must be filed with the opening brief, not after the court signals doubts.
Sources
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit: Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (opinion)
- Bloomberg Law: Court Rejects Industry, Labor Challenge to EPA Asbestos Rule
- InsideEPA: Rejecting Challenges, 5th Circuit Lets EPA’s TSCA Asbestos Rule Stand
- Law360: 5th Circ. Denies EPA Asbestos Rule Challenges Over Standing
