Skip to content

Eighth Circuit Puts Army’s Lead Azide Detonation in Iowa on Hold

A federal appeals court has paused an Environmental Protection Agency permit that would have allowed the U.S. Army to blow up nearly five tons of degraded lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown, Iowa, while judges weigh a challenge from two environmental groups.

In a one-sentence order entered late Thursday, Nov. 19, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit granted an administrative stay of the EPA’s emergency permit “until the emergency motion for stay is ruled upon by this court.” The order sets no date, leaving the planned detonation on hold for now.

Groups Challenge an Emergency Permit

The Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club’s Iowa Chapter, represented by Earthjustice, filed a petition for review and an emergency motion targeting the permit the EPA issued on Nov. 13 under federal hazardous waste law. The case is docketed as Iowa Environmental Council v. EPA, No. 26-3374.

The groups argue the agency signed off without requiring the Army to seriously evaluate safer disposal methods, without adequate protections for nearby residents, and without giving affected communities timely notice. They also contend that the evidence the EPA relied on has not been made public, making it impossible for residents to test the agency’s conclusions.

According to the filing, the Army’s own modeling shows lead-bearing dust could settle across a zone roughly 25 miles long and 5 miles wide, reaching homes, farmland and waterways. The groups warn that lead deposited in soil could keep exposing people, livestock and wildlife long after the blast.

Why the Army Wants to Detonate

Lead azide is a primary explosive used to set off munitions. The plant has stored 68 barrels of it, about 10,000 pounds in total, for more than two decades, kept stable in a mix of ethanol and water. An inspection this year found that some of the liquid had evaporated, and the EPA has said the material has recrystallized, making it more sensitive to friction and shock.

The Army maintains that moving the containers would risk an accidental explosion and that destroying the material in place is the only responsible option. Two controlled blasts had been scheduled for midday Friday, Nov. 20, before the Army pushed them to Monday, which acting Army Secretary Adam Telle described as the latest workable moment before colder weather could further destabilize the explosive.

Political Pressure and Next Steps

A bipartisan group of Iowa and Illinois officials, including Sens. Dick Durbin and Tammy Duckworth and Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, urged the Pentagon and EPA to delay the detonation and explore alternatives. In a joint statement, the Army, EPA and Department of Health and Human Services said they were prepared to use extreme mitigation measures to protect the public.

The Justice Department told the court it intends to file its opposition to the emergency motion by Sunday. The Eighth Circuit will then decide whether to keep the permit frozen while the challenge proceeds.

Sources