A federal judge in Manhattan on Friday, Nov. 20, 2026, turned down a request to keep a set of taxpayer-funded television ads featuring President Donald Trump off the air indefinitely. She ruled that the challengers had not shown a pressing, ongoing injury now that the November elections have been decided.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon of the Southern District of New York denied the plaintiffs’ latest request for emergency relief. She also refused to dismiss the case, so the broader fight over whether the government could lawfully pay for the spots will continue.
What the Lawsuit Challenges
The case, Common Cause v. Department of Homeland Security, was filed in October by the watchdog group Common Cause, Alabama state House candidate Robert Hunter, Service Employees International Union Local 32BJ and the union’s affiliated political action committee. They target a $20 million advertising contract that the Department of Homeland Security signed after the Office of Management and Budget moved funds that Congress had appropriated for border security.
According to the complaint, the ads praise the president and repeat his attacks on Democratic opponents, yet each one closes with a “Paid for by the U.S. Government” disclaimer. One spot was largely lifted from Trump’s 2024 campaign. The plaintiffs argue that the spending goes beyond what Congress authorized and breaks federal limits on using appropriated money for “publicity or propaganda.”
From Emergency Order to Denial
Rochon moved quickly before Election Day. In mid-October she blocked the ads from airing through the midterms, finding the challengers were likely to show that the expenditures were not authorized. She later extended the order to three newer ads, including one in which Trump promised Americans $5,000 if Republicans won.
The situation looks different now, the judge wrote. Hunter lost his race for Alabama House District 28, and the Nov. 3 contests the union and its PAC had pointed to are over. Rochon called arguments about backing candidates in future races “too speculative and non-imminent” to support more emergency relief, and she said hypothetical future elections are not emergencies currently before the court.
Why the Case Stays Alive
The administration had argued that the end of the election made the dispute moot. Rochon disagreed. She noted that the government continues to defend the ads, has not canceled the contract and has not said it plans to stop running them. She added that future elections could pass before courts finish deciding whether the spending was lawful.
Parallel Challenges in Washington
The New York case is one of three legal fights over the ads. In Washington, D.C., the Democratic National Committee has challenged the government’s use of public funds and federal staff to produce the videos and related social media content. U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan previously issued a temporary restraining order in that case and heard arguments on a longer-term injunction on Thursday. A third suit, brought by the Democratic Party of Wisconsin, concerns how the ads affected a candidate for Wisconsin state treasurer.
Because Rochon declined to act, the next major decision on whether the ads can return to the airwaves is likely to come from the D.C. court.
