Skip to content

Judge Orders Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to Rein In Religious Emails to USDA Staff

A federal judge in San Francisco ruled Thursday, November 19, 2026, that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins likely crossed a constitutional line when she used her official email account to send Christian-themed holiday messages to the entire U.S. Department of Agriculture workforce.

U.S. District Judge Trina L. Thompson granted a preliminary injunction sought by a group of USDA employees, concluding that at least two of the messages amounted to the kind of religious coercion the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause forbids.

What the Employees Challenged

Seven named plaintiffs, who describe themselves as a multifaith and nonreligious group of USDA workers, sued the department and Rollins in her official capacity. They pointed to a string of agency-wide emails tied to holidays such as Independence Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter, which they said grew steadily more evangelistic.

Two messages drew the most attention. A December 23, 2025, Christmas video described Jesus Christ as the gift that opened “the door to eternal life,” and an April 5, 2026, Easter note compared agency employees to the first disciples. The employees argued the department has roughly 100,000 workers who cannot opt out of the secretary’s emails.

Why the Court Found Coercion

Judge Thompson said three factors pushed the messages past ordinary holiday greetings: Rollins sits at the top of the agency’s chain of command, she used an official account to reach every employee, and the wording could leave workers who do not share her faith feeling excluded. The December and April emails, she wrote, “go too far.”

The court also rejected the idea that staff could simply ignore the messages. Because the secretary uses the same account for announcements on reorganizations and shutdown planning, the judge reasoned, employees are effectively expected to read everything she sends.

Notably, the order borrows its limits from Rollins’ own November 2025 guidance on religious expression in the federal workplace. Under the injunction, she must stop if a colleague asks, may not create a hostile environment, and may not use official authority to pressure subordinates. She remains free to discuss her faith with interested coworkers. “Why should the secretary be exempt from her own rules?” the judge wrote.

What the Ruling Does Not Do

The decision is not a final judgment. Judge Thompson dismissed the employees’ separate claims under the Administrative Procedure Act, finding the emails were not a final agency action, and she stressed that the court takes no position on what Rollins may say in her personal capacity. The constitutional claim will continue toward further proceedings, and the government may seek review of the injunction.

Sources