A New York personal-injury lawsuit against Madison Square Garden’s parent company has produced an unusual side dispute: the plaintiff’s own lawyers have been told they cannot enter the arena.
The Letter
On September 28, 2026, MSG Entertainment notified attorneys at Mark David Shirian P.C., a Manhattan firm, that they could no longer enter Madison Square Garden while litigation against the company remained unresolved. The firm represents Nino Ufie in a personal-injury suit against MSG Arena, LLC, Madison Square Garden Entertainment Corp. and MSG Entertainment Holdings, LLC, filed in New York Supreme Court on August 14, 2026.
According to reporting by EssentiallySports, the letter said the firm represented “one or more plaintiffs in litigation against Madison Square Garden Entertainment Corp., or one or more of its affiliates or subsidiaries.” It extended the bar to Radio City Music Hall, the Beacon Theatre, The Chicago Theatre and the Infosys Theater at MSG, and declared previously purchased tickets “revoked and deemed revoked, void and invalid.”
A Policy With a Public Record
The restriction applies a rule MSG has defended openly for years. In a January 2023 statement, the company said: “Attorneys who have filed a lawsuit against MSG Entertainment are not welcome in our venues while litigation is ongoing. When the litigation is resolved, they will be welcomed back.”
James Dolan, MSG’s controlling owner, echoed that position in a FOX 5 interview the same month: “If somebody sues you, that’s confrontational… And it’s fine. People are allowed to sue, right? But at the same time, if you’re being sued, you don’t have to welcome the person into your home.”
The company has said the policy covers lawyers handling personal-injury claims, class actions and ticket-reseller matters, while excluding sexual-harassment and employment-discrimination cases. ESPN reported in 2025 that more than 1,000 lawyers at roughly 90 firms had been barred since 2022, a figure MSG disputed.
The Lawyer on the Other Side
Attorney Mark D. Shirian founded his firm in 2016 and practices in personal injury, employment law and sports and entertainment law, according to the firm’s website. That profile lists multiple seven-figure settlements, a $1.5 million recovery for a client under New York’s Child Victim Act, and recognition as one of The National Trial Lawyers’ Top 40 Under 40. He is admitted in New York and in the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York.
Those credentials made the firm’s response notable. Rather than step back, the firm’s attorneys, Shirian and Shawn D. Shirian, both described as longtime Knicks fans, remain counsel in a case that was still open in Supreme Court at the time of the reports.
Brooklyn Responds
Days after the letter, Brooklyn Sports & Entertainment’s premium hospitality team invited Shirian and his team to the October 8 Nets-76ers game at Barclays Center. The invitation said the company wanted to “learn more about the company and the work you are doing.”
The exchange leaves the two arenas sending opposite messages: one barring a firm until its case ends, the other offering it a seat.
